Problem/Issue Statement
What is the problem?
- The problem that Pandora has encountered is that they are currently at a crossroads, in that they need to turn revenue generation into profits.
- According to current growth rates, the company will exhaust its cash flow by years end.
- Pandora needs to maximize revenue and reduce costs.
What is the distinction between the problems and the symptoms?
- Pandora needed a professional CEO, they needed a more consumer oriented executive that had direct-to-consumer product experience (which Westergren lacked).
- The company does not invest in any advertising and they are not producing enough revenue to maintain operations.
What is the scope of the problem?
- The scope of the problem was two fold: they needed to bring in a new CEO as well as figure out in which direction to turn to raise additional capital (or which company to turn to).
Situation Assessment
What is the context of the problem?
- The context of the problem is the ever changing landscape of the music industry.
- It also includes Pandora’s inability to advertise to new customers and expand their market share, thus hindering its ability to be profitable prior to becoming an Internet radio service. The gross margin Pandora received per listener was approximately $.69cents per hour.
What are the decision criteria?
- Continue to differentiate themselves by offering a free service, in using targeting advertising to it's subscribers.
- Pandora needs to reach new customers across different platforms (mobile usage being a key component of that approach).
- Offering a premium subscription in which customers would be able to listen commercial free for a premium.
List
of Plausible Alternative Courses of Action
What are the
alternative courses of action?
- Increase the amount of ads. The addition of advertisements will help cover their royalty fees. The more users that click on ads, the more fees to be paid to Pandora from advertisers as well as the amount initially paid to simply have the ads on that forum.
- Premium subscription model. Pandora could implement a subscription model that would cost users roughly $3 per month in that they will be able to listen to as much as they want without advertisements and stoppages to music streaming.
- Flexible "freemium" service. After after 40 hours of music the user would be charged roughly $1 up to stream another 40 hours of music. This assumes that advertising would remain level. Limited monthly usage may deter new users.
- Do nothing, continue as is.
- Change to an add based model. Targeted advertising allows for referrals, which can lead to commission fees if users click-through and purchase. Subscribers have ability to reduce the frequency of ads by answering questions about music preferences, or contributing their input on song categorization, etc to help expand the library.
Evaluation of Alternatives
Through what theoretical concepts should
one evaluation of the alternatives?
- Pandora should consider what is best for the company moving forward in the next few years. Whether that be charging their subscribers a premium or increasing the advertisements. They need attract new listeners, make money, yet not push current customers away.
How does the evaluation relate to the
decision criteria developed?
- The evaluation should take into account that the company does not have enough cash flow to continue doing business as is, therefore that option should be ruled out immediately. To sustain business life, Pandora will need to change the way in which they do business.
How imaginative can/should the
evaluation be?
- I feel the evaluation should be creative...yet realistic. They need to adapt their current business model as well as be aware that this will not be the end all/be all for them as the music industry is always changing (as they've seen before).
Recommendation
- I would recommend that Pandora uses a hybrid approach in implementing a business model using a combination of offering a premium subscription in which users can listen commercial free as well as an ad based model. They cannot rely solely on premium paying customers as well as they cannot rely on their free listening customers as well. Finding a happy medium between the two platforms would suit Pandora best.
- This hybrid approach gives customers the ability to stay on as free users by listening to the advertisements, or they can choose a subscription model that reduces the amount of advertising for the customer. This also goes one step further by using subscriber input to allow for targeted advertisements.
Presentation
- If I were presenting this case I would present how the music industry is ever changing and show figures of declining CD (album) sales and the rise of digital music sales. Exhibit 5 would be a good chart to include to show the rise of digital sales over the sale of CD's.
- A power point presentation outlining the pros and cons of each alternative (along with current business practices) would be a great visual aid.
- I would stress that Pandora does need to change but also realizes this change could be temporary and that they need to keep their eyes open for the next wave of technology in the music industry and be ready to capitalize on that.

No comments:
Post a Comment