Andersen Consulting separated from the parent company Arthur Andersen and was renamed Accenture in 2001. Accenture had in essence rebranded themselves and was now faced with the challenge of building a new IT
infrastructure to support a global organization that consulted on
leading-edge technology. They only had one year to implement a new IT system and they were not keen on using the same system that was in place at Arthur Andersen. They now faced the problem
of whether or not they should adopt COBIT 5 IT standards which is a framework for
IT governance and control. The scope of the problem for
Accenture is that it has 180,000 employees in more than 50 locations around the world.
I believe that there are two alternative courses of action that they can take:
- A Decentralized Approach: This being in that the different countries that Accenture operates in where basically to fend for themselves. Each country would choose it's own IT platform and had the autonomy to run them. I do not see this as a feasible solution as running multiple applications will it very difficult to share information between the units. The costs would be a factor in that training fees across different platforms will be required as well as different maintenance and implementation costs to keep the programs up and running.
- A Centralized Approach: All offices are interconnected and run off the same IT platform. This would reduce the cost of training as well as offer the ability to easily share information across locations.
One of the centralized options is to adopt COBIT 5. COBIT 5 creates value by finding a
balance between realizing benefits and optimizing risks. It considers the
IT related interests of internal and external stakeholders. It is based
on 5 principles and 7 enablers:
- Principle 1: Meeting Stakeholder Needs
- Principle 2: Covering the Enterprise End-to- End
- Principle 3: Applying a Single, Integrated Framework
- Principle 4: Enabling a Holistic Approach
- Principle 5: Separating Governance From Management
- Enabler 1: Principles, policies and frameworks
- Enabler 2: Processes
- Enabler 3: Organizational structures
- Enabler 4: Culture, ethics, and behavior
- Enabler 5: Information
- Enabler 6: Services, infrastructure and applications
- Enabler 7: People, skills and competencies
There are really only two
courses of action Accenture can consider include continuing to operate
without any change or implementing the COBIT 5 framework.
If Accenture
continues to operate without change they will be a system that
has transformed their IT and overall business processes successfully on a
global level. Accenture
achieved higher revenues, more efficiency, and cost reduction through
leveraged globalization, cross-border labor arbitrage, simplified IT platforms,
single vendors, SAP, and ROI oriented budgets. If they continue to operate as
is, no further training for employees is required and they will continue to generate similar results.
If they choose to implement COBIT 5, that would require altering the existing infrastructure to satisfy
standards and adhere to the government and management principles. The switch over to COBIT 5
would involve training through services such as in-person, online, and
on-site programs. Training and implementation will provide resources that
ensure that information and technology investments and use of IT assets
effectively support enterprise goals. COBIT 5 brings together
stakeholders across an organization for more effective decision-making
with consistent standards, quality and control. The approximate cost to implement COBIT 5 over a 3 year period is approximately $48 million.
Reflection:
After the meeting with Strategic IT Consulting's presentation, I stand behind my decision to stay with our current IT platform. The consultants did a great job in assessing our current practices as well as address from all angles if we were to adopt the COBIT 5 framework. My greatest concerns are in the implementation of this new platform
such as new costs of equipment, more training, and the risk of it not
aligning with the current processes. The cost of implementation is also a concern of mine as the cost is roughly $48 million over a 3 year period. In implementing COBIT 5, we would have to train 500 employees every 3
years are additional costs that are unnecessary for us to incur. The COBIT 5 discipline
forces us to apply metrics and would make our system even more complex. Had this proposed move come, say in 2001 (when Accenture came about), I would have been much more receptive towards making the switch to COBIT 5 but I feel we are too far along and our IT processes and business model work hand in hand with one another and will
ultimately continue to bring us a positive return on investment. I am all for welcoming change but presently, our current state of affairs suits our organization best. 