Tuesday, February 19, 2013

1-888-JUNK-VAN








Problem/Issue Statement

·         Marcus Kingo is currently facing a problem in which way he should turn in regards to managing information handling errors that are presently on the rise and is worried about losing 1-888-JUNK-VAN customers.

·         Kingo’s operation is encountering problems due to the fact that they do not have a true IT system and business is suffering (periods of time where they cannot schedule new jobs, drivers being given misinformation).

·         The scope of the problem is that Kingo wishes to remain under a mobile business without a physical “brick and mortar” office.  But, this is proving to be more and more difficult as the waste management business in Canada is becoming more competitive and his current online system is becoming more problematic.

Situation Assessment

·         The context of the problem is that they are finding problems in the way that current jobs are being booked, information being passed along to their drivers, and overall inefficiencies with their entire system.

·         The decision criteria I feel is based on ease of use, ability to grow with the company, there cannot be much if any downtime, and most importantly how much it will cost.

List of Plausible Alternative Courses of Action

There are 5 plausible alternatives that Kingo has found:

Microsoft Access Database
·         Pros: Very little down time in implementing software.  Could be installed personally by Kingo (on weekends and evenings) on multiple computers and capable of remote access. 
   
    Cons: Unsure of how many licenses would be needed.  Local installations would not allow for remote access and personally I do not think is much improvement on current system in place.

Custom Application
·         Pros: Remote access, custom built system tailored to the company’s needs.
·         Cons: Would take approximately 4 weeks to construct.  $2,000 up front price and maintenance fees run $60 per hour per developer.  Did not include data migration and software could not be seen beforehand.

Google Documents
·         Pros: Minimal cost, up to 10 accounts at $5 per month or $50 per user per year.
·         Cons: Could not be cross-referenced.  Lack of formal customer support.

Platform as a Service (PaaS)
·         Pros: Cloud-computing infrastructure. Information could be found on demand via internet. Data migration takes 3 days.
·         Cons: Price, packages range from $300-600 per month and customization runs $180 per hour.  Kingo is worried he may not be tech savvy enough to operate this system.

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) System
Pros: Remote accessibility.  Integrated throughout the entire business processes covering every aspect of the business.  Easily can accommodate 20-25 users.
Cons: Kingo is not sure if this will address his business needs.  Very costly, “starting pack” runs $12,000 for 4 licenses.

Evaluation of Alternatives

·         I feel the best way to evaluate all of the alternatives is to line them up side by side and assess the pros and cons of each system against each other.

·         Kingo can see any area in which he sees would be a positive for his business or a negative.  Whichever one most closely fits his business needs will come to the surface.

·         I think there is room to be very imaginative in considering which business system to pursue but also stay within the bounds of legality for the waste management industry.

Recommendation
·         A quality recommendation would be to implement something that has all of his needs in mind; email automation, remote access, ease of implementation, price.  I think a logical short term solution would be to pursue either the PaaS or ERP solution.

·         A logical recommendation would be to pursue a PaaS system.  Yes, it would be much more expensive to implement but you are saving money in not having a “brick & mortar” location but in order to greatly expand, you would have to upgrade your system at some point and this method will have the ability to expand with the business.

Presentation
·         If I were presenting, in summing up this case I would present it as a small operation who is having some decent success right now but in order to take that leap in really becoming a major player in the waste management industry, changes have to be made.

·         I would make a Visio chart showing the pros and cons of each alternative as well as chart the proposed expenses of implementing and operating each system.
·         I would “sell” it in that if you want to remain the same size, stay as you are.  But, if you are looking to expand your business you need to change the way the business systems are run.

·         I would look for the group to adequately address each alternative and address why the system they are behind is superlative.  I would also look for them to address what will happen to Kingo if they remain the same.

Case Reflection
 I was impressed with the job the consultants did in their presentation.  Taking into consideration their presentation as well as after doing a little research myself, I agree that Mr. Kingo should pursue a PaaS (which in reality would be a SaaS) system.  I feel this is the best course of action for him and would equate making the switch to leasing a car as that he would be renting the software and everything that comes along with it.  I think Mr. Kingo has no other recourse if he wants his business to expand and ultimately be successful.




No comments:

Post a Comment